(Click the link to comment and to vote – voting not working through email, sorry!)
Note: conundrums are not meant to have a “right” answer – they are to see how most people are practicing. Would love your comments also regarding your thought processes and the evidence behind your decisions. We can learn from each other!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b33d2/b33d24abd07428d63d24153592f2f6830e9ff9a5" alt="Loading ... Loading ..."
July 27, 2019 at 4:59 am
A nice summary of available evidence can be found in Gottlieb M et al: What to do after you cut: recommendations for abscess management in the emergency setting. Ann Emerg Med 2018;71:31-33, an Annals EM and EM:RAP partnership article. The authors’ conclusions are: ultrasonography is useful if the diagnosis is not clinically obvious, small (< 5 cm) abscesses may not need packing but larger abscesses should still be packed pending larger trials, loop drainage is a potential alternative to I&D + packing, consider antibiotics even for uncomplicated abscesses because they lead to a higher cure rate (NNT 7-14).